Denver Digital Marketing Agency Launches AEO Services – New Audit Finds 87% of Colorado Businesses Invisible in AI Search

A new audit conducted by Denver digital marketing agency NEWMEDIA.COM has found that a majority of Colorado companies remain virtually invisible to artificial intelligence search tools—even when they perform well on Google.

The research analyzed 200 Denver-area businesses currently ranking on the first page of Google for their primary keywords. When the same keywords were entered into AI-driven platforms such as ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, and Google’s AI Overviews, 87 percent of those companies did not appear once in AI-generated results.

The findings highlight a rapid transformation in how customers discover and evaluate businesses. AI-powered search tools are becoming the default for both consumers and B2B buyers seeking trusted recommendations. As these systems begin to replace traditional search behavior, visibility within AI-generated results is becoming a new determinant of brand credibility and revenue potential.

Also Read: AiThority Interview with Jonathan Kershaw, Director of Product Management, Vonage

According to the audit, the visibility gap is primarily due to differences in how AI systems establish authority. Unlike Google’s algorithm, which relies heavily on keyword optimization, backlinks, and on-page structure, AI engines prioritize citation-based trust signals—including third-party validation, structured case studies, award listings, and consistent mentions in credible media outlets. Without these external references, many businesses remain unrecognized within AI knowledge graphs.

The audit also revealed that AI tools disproportionately reference verified databases such as Clutch, Built In Colorado, and Expertise.com, which aggregate company information, reviews, and editorial profiles. Businesses with minimal representation on these third-party platforms were found to have the lowest likelihood of citation in AI responses.

“AI models can’t interpret reputation the way humans do,” a NEWMEDIA.COM Denver spokesperson said. “If your authority isn’t structured, validated, and publicly documented, you’re effectively invisible. Even long-established firms with excellent reputations can disappear from AI-generated search results if their proof points aren’t machine-readable.”

The implications extend across industries. According to data from Digital Strategy Review, 43 percent of professionals now use AI tools for research and vendor selection, a figure expected to grow significantly through 2026. Mid-market companies that have invested heavily in traditional SEO are particularly exposed, as many lack the media presence and third-party validation that AI relies upon to determine expertise.

One Denver firm featured in the audit illustrated this trend. Despite a decade of strong Google rankings and a solid local reputation, the company failed to appear in ChatGPT’s recommendations for “Denver marketing agencies.” Meanwhile, three competitors—each newer and smaller—were consistently cited across AI tools due to greater validation through review platforms and public case studies. Within six months, the firm recorded a 25 percent decline in inbound leads.

To help address this gap, NEWMEDIA.COM Denver has launched an AI Visibility Assessment, a complimentary evaluation designed to help businesses identify where they do or do not appear across leading AI platforms. The process reviews citation sources, authority signals, and content structures, providing specific recommendations to strengthen visibility and data accuracy.

“AI visibility isn’t about manipulating algorithms,” the spokesperson added. “It’s about creating verifiable proof of expertise—data that both people and machines can trust.”

Also Read: A Pulse Check on AI in the Boardroom: Balancing Innovation and Risk in an Era of Regulatory Scrutiny